Coulter and Partec

From: paolo <paolo+@pitt.edu>
Date: Fri Jun 10 2005 - 14:53:58 EST
Dear flow experts, Greetings to all  of you.

Our lab needs a 5 color (dual laser, 488 and 635)  cytometer that can read samples from a 96 well plate format, and I am looking for some help in choosing between two instruments.

To my knowledge, what is available in the US market at this time is: (1) the Coulter Cytomics FC500 MPL and (2) the Partec CyFlow Space equipped with the RobbyWell.

Does anyone have any knowledge of these two?

There are several elements that will influence the decision:

1) Quality: I was told that Partec uses microscope lenses to collect/detect signal and this considerably  increases the sensitivity. Also they have absolute cells counting.

2) Price.  the Partec cytometer is at least  20% less expensive than  Coulter's. Also for little more money it is possible to get one additional detector to make it into a 6 color machine. 

3) Service: Coulter is produced in the US and they have a large customer base. Based on personal experience on the two XLs we have now, Coulter's service is,  just to be short, excellent. Interestingly the cost of the service contract for the Partec machines is less than Coulter's: the reason for this is that they need less repairs (I was told).

It will be quite an investment for our lab, so any suggestions, comments etc  will be greatly appreciated.


Thanks
=======================

 

Paolo

=======================

aut viam inveniam aut faciam

=======================

 

Paolo Piazza, PhD

425 Parran Hall

Infectious Diseases and Microbiology

GSPH - University of Pittsburgh

tel (412) 624 – 3130

fax (412) 624 – 4953

e-mail   paolo@pitt.edu

 

Received on Mon Jun 13 14:18:00 2005

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Sat Jan 14 2006 - 22:03:47 EST